Viking | 2018
Opening Hook: Full “once upon a time” style.
Main Character: A young stepmother who my step kids should be nicer to!
Plot Twisty-ness: As slow as watching kids warm up to dad’s new wife.
Just like other reviews aplenty will tell you, this novel is inspired by another classic novel and blah blah blah. I don’t know the book. I might know the author’s name? I’ve never read it and I didn’t know any of this “inspiration” shit going into the book so it really makes zero difference to me whatsoever.
Look, I never claimed to be a refined reader.
I read this novel purely for the gothic feel of the synopsis and because I’m a stepmother married to an older(ish) man and those themes resonate with me. I haven’t found many stories centring on stepmothers/second wives, which are actually mystery/thrillers that don’t paint people like me as some ridiculous evil creature to be feared and ousted.
I wagered, because this book was told from the stepmother’s point of view, there was a good chance she wasn’t the villain per se. And thankfully, I was right! The stepmother isn’t the villain for once! She’s more of a saviour, which is totally how I see myself, just with less like doing things that make anyone’s life better and more being peeved that I never get to play my PlayStation anymore that I bought a second one out of passive aggressive spite. It’s how I roll.
The Winters are Max and Dani. A father and daughter duo who lost their wife/mother just a year earlier. The wounds are still fresh and Dani, especially, is still having trouble coping with the loss of her mother, which of course, turns out to not be as straight forward as it’s first presented.
Max, a senator from Long Island and heir to the Winters’ forture, meets our unnamed narrator where she lives in the Cayman Island working at a boating company for tourists. A whirlwind romance over the course of a couple of weeks sees her engaged and relocated to the Winters’ estate, Asherley. The Narrator tries to connect with Dani while side-stepping the dead wife’s shadow and memories at every turn.
This part of the novel felt very real to me. Though my husband and his ex-wife have a complicated relationship that comes with zero good feelings towards each other, you do still feel “second” for a long time. You feel like your walking a tight-rope, trying to figure out how to make it across to a peaceful place without getting hurt. Being a second wife is difficult. Being a second wife and stepmother is even harder.
My relationship with my stepkids has always been pretty easy – save for some tumultuous recent teen years with the oldest – so Dani’s petty torturing and attitude towards the new Mrs. Winter didn’t connect for me personally, though I do know lots of stepmoms (from a support group) who have dealt with something similar. The “angry teen who doesn’t want you to be in her life” is a very real thing that a lot of stepmothers I know have had their hearts broken over.
If you’re a stepmother reading this and you’re having a hard time with it, just know that I get it. It’s a tricky situation that often leaves you feeling isolated and rejected and resentful. And I definitely felt this from the book, along with a side of optimism. The new Mrs. Winter just won’t quick trying to make Dani like her. I was never that much of a go-getter with my own stepkids, mostly because I didn’t want to be overbearing or weird, but I get the instincts displayed in the book.
Personally, I think the author just got it. Maybe she’s a stepmother herself, or maybe she’s had one. Either way, I give most of my stars just for this aspect of the novel alone.
The atmosphere of Asherley was intriguing and visceral, but aside from that, I found the plot to be a little ho-hum. If there was supposed to be a feeling of something sinister happening at the estate, or happening to the narrator, it was lost in the pages and pages detailing the family drama/history.
There are definitely elements of mystery and suspense to the plot – casting Dani as an unreliable narrator, for instance. Some characters were easy to make seem suspicious, so those moments were readily taken, but it felt like a bit of a cheesy cop-out. For the most part, I would call this a contemporary drama that just samples a little bit of those darker sides of fiction, but never goes full throttle with them.
It’s definitely a slow burner of a novel. It takes a long time to lay out how the relationship starts, the engagement, the move and planning the wedding. It’s not until the day of the wedding, which is near the 80% mark of the book, that things start to really pick up and the truths start to be revealed about the first wife’s death and Dani’s mental health.
Because it took so long to get to the important moments of revelation and comeuppance, the reading time didn’t feel totally worth it to me. The suspense and twists fell flat during the climax, and the small moments that were laid as breadcrumbs during the buildup to that moment, were easily forgettable because we moved passed them so quickly.
I did find Lisa Gabriele’s writing really easy to get into, though. It’s naturally descriptive, painting the setting and atmosphere really beautifully without feeling forceful or obvious. But I was expecting this to be more of a thriller so all of the beautiful writing didn’t really lend itself to creating a pace that was “page-turning.”
As a piece of fiction, it will really resonate with anyone who’s ever been a second wife or a stepmother. Emotionally, I think this book knocks it out of the park in that respect. But as a thriller or mystery, it’s a little plain and won’t work for readers who are used to big twists and shocking scenes.
Well written, but not riveting.
Inspired by Daphne du Maurier’s Rebecca, a spellbindingly suspenseful novel set in the moneyed world of the Hamptons, about secrets that refuse to remain buried and consequences that can’t be escaped
After a whirlwind romance, a young woman returns to the opulent, secluded Long Island mansion of her new fiancé Max Winter—a wealthy politician and recent widower—and a life of luxury she’s never known. But all is not as it appears at the Asherley estate. The house is steeped in the memory of Max’s beautiful first wife Rebekah, who haunts the young woman’s imagination and feeds her uncertainties, while his very alive teenage daughter Dani makes her life a living hell. She soon realizes there is no clear place for her in this twisted little family: Max and Dani circle each other like cats, a dynamic that both repels and fascinates her, and he harbors political ambitions with which he will allow no woman—alive or dead—to interfere.
As the soon-to-be second Mrs. Winter grows more in love with Max, and more afraid of Dani, she is drawn deeper into the family’s dark secrets—the kind of secrets that could kill her, too. The Winters is a riveting story about what happens when a family’s ghosts resurface and threaten to upend everything.